Law Offices of Paul K. Schrier, PLLC

Is it time to take away that old guy's driver's license?

Throughout Florida, we hear the common cry every time a senior citizen causes a car accident, "Can't we take away their driver's license?!" According to WorldAtlas, Florida currently leads the nation with 2.7 million drivers over the age of 65; roughly 19 percent of all drivers on the roads. Despite special rules the Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (DHSMV) has put in place for seniors to retain their driver's licenses, we still lead the nation in the number of fatal car accidents involving older drivers.

The deadliest year

The National Safety Council (NSC) recently reported that 2016 proved to be the deadliest year for Florida drivers and passengers, with more than 1,600 people losing their lives in accidents involving motor vehicles. While age statistics for 2016 fatalities aren't yet available, a 2010 article in the SunSentinel reported that 503 car crashes resulting in a fatality involved a senior citizen behind the wheel. It can probably be assumed that the percentages will be roughly the same for 2016.

So, are senior drivers really a problem?

We've all heard the complaints about senior citizens. Many local drivers say there are too many retired people who move to Florida and don't know the roads. Some have eyesight or hearing trouble that causes problems in low light or visibility. With age comes delayed reaction time and many can't cope with faster traffic buzzing around them.

But to say that senior drivers cause the high accident rates doesn't reflect reality. In many cases, senior citizens have gone through defensive driver courses and remedial training to retain or renew their driver's licenses. Matthew Ubben, president of Floridians for Better Transportation says that much of the problem with increased accidents among senior drivers has to do with poorly designed roads. Many roads were designed and built decades ago, when they accommodated significantly less traffic at lower speeds. The group has asked the Florida legislature for more than $415 million in revenue from the driver's license and tab fund to go toward new road construction projects.

In addition, local driving patterns may be unfamiliar to people of any age who are new to a community. One example is the center "suicide" turn lane along much of Highways 1 and the A1A along the Eastern Atlantic Coast.

Older drivers feel the pressure and many do something about it

Under Florida law, every six years all drivers over 80 must pass a vision test at the DHSMV office or have a doctor administer the test. The state may deny the renewal or place other restrictions on drivers who don't meet minimum requirements.

Simply taking away the driver's licenses of senior citizens isn't the right answer, nor would it necessarily reduce accident rates. Many seniors realize their skills behind the wheel are diminished so they slow down and drive more carefully. Many others enroll in special training courses available online or through community education programs. Unfortunately, many drivers of younger generations would not participate in remedial driving classes unless ordered by a court because of traffic violations.

A good list of these courses can be found at the Senior Safety Resource Center website.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

You Pay No Fee Unless We Win

  • $3.1 million

    Recovered for a client in a Commercial Truck Collision case in Jacksonville.

  • $1.3 million

    Recovered for a client in a Personal Injury case in Fort Lauderdale.

  • $3.0 million

    Recovered for a client in a Premises Liability case in Orlando.

  • $1.5 million

    Recovered for a client in an Inadequate Security case in Miami.

Email us for response

Get A Free Case Evaluation.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Sunrise Office
1072 Sunset Strip
Sunrise, FL 33313

Phone: 954-271-1859
Fax: 800-768-9147
Map & Directions

Miami Office
11098 Biscayne Boulevard
Suite 208
Miami, FL 33161

Phone: 305-330-3833
Fax: 800-768-9147
Map & Directions

Orlando Office
618 E. South Street
Suite 500
Orlando, FL 32801

Phone: 407-434-0931
Fax: 800-768-9147
Map & Directions

Jacksonville Office
841 Prudential Drive
12th Floor, Suite 101
Jacksonville, FL 32207

Phone: 904-236-4362
Fax: 800-768-9147
Map & Directions

Tampa Office
8270 Woodland Center Blvd
Suite 301
Tampa, FL 33614

Phone: 813-337-7941
Fax: 800-768-9147
Map & Directions

Back To Top